Comments on: Philippine Idol Disappointment

By: mary

mary — Mon, 11 Sep 2006 12:41:53 +0000

tama yung comment na the show lacks viewership. ito ang problema dito. i think wala masyadong bumoto except yung mga kamag-anak at kaibigan ng contestants kaya ang laban eh paramihan ng mga kakilala. sana abs or gma na nga lang naghandle ng show para at least maraming voters. i’m sure makukuha yung mga magagaling pag maraming voters pero konti lang talaga eh. hmp!

By: deja_dead

deja_dead — Mon, 11 Sep 2006 11:19:14 +0000

i agree that Phil Idol lacks publicity. If it was shown in either of the 2 biggest networks, it would have been millions of voters.me mga flying voters pa yun!
im not happy with the results.sa male category, ok sa akin si draey and reymond.sa female,si pow lang ang ok dun e.si armari,ok lang siguro.pero si jelli saka c apple?!duh!i hate them when they sing.pa-cute!this is a singing contest not some cheap beauty pageant. cant they show more of their talents in singing.nakakatawa si jelli nung kumakanta.hindi cia ok mag-interpret ng song.hehe even in portuguese.hahaha!

By: Jay

Jay — Sun, 10 Sep 2006 13:46:40 +0000

I really prefer Philippine Idol over other talent searches sa ibang network. Simple lang kasi ang format ng Philippine idol (american idol). It is really text votes that count. NO POLITICS. Sa ABS di ba sinasabi madami daw politics (like noong nanalo si Eric Santos — where is he now?). Eh dito, may credibility si Mr C. He is not a Simon Cowell , but my God, iyong mga matitinong nagaudition, they know the calibre of the judges (si Francis, aminin man o hindi, set the trent for Pinoy pop). Si Pilita naman, helped many talents na. Eh sa GMA, ano ba ang ginawa sa mga talents, binaboy nila . Imagine ipalabas ang dirty laundry noong scam sa botohan noong star search nila (the computer incident ni arci na taga UP, nakakahiya).

I just hope malinis ang sa philippine idol. it is also good na mukhang na weed out na iyong mga basurang singers. so at least, kung sino ang manalo, at least madunong kumanta ng tama.

Only thing is, siempre sa pilipinas, malakas ang hatak ng mga kamag-anak. the larger the clan or the click group , the bigger the chance the manalo (text votes di ba)? so iyon ang downfall. kung sakaling isabak ang manalo (and suppose nanalo lang sia due to kamag-anaks), palpak sigurado. i just hope ABC 5 would be able to PROMOTE well ang philippine idol. we have so many good singers.

By: Sam Nowailati

Sam Nowailati — Sat, 09 Sep 2006 08:30:38 +0000

all the comments u said about miguel because he didnt choose the right song i know miguel he sings on my piano he has the voice but with the right song he is not a profesional he is a good singer with hidden talents he can make a diffrence in this industry and he will be the first philippine idol. most of the other contestant are profesionals miguel is just a singer that sings in church!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

By: WakkaBalls

WakkaBalls — Fri, 08 Sep 2006 14:19:48 +0000

Finally somebody shares the same sentiments as I do. I would consider it a controversy because some who got in (Miguel and Jan), do not deserve to take a spot in the final four. The only reason they got in is because of their popularity such as that from Miguel being from La Salle who got most of the campus votersâ€™ nod while Jan being from Uniliver. I feel very sorry for those who performed exceptional (Gian, Ramirr, Robert) but did not make it. Even the three judges favored them, but the voters decided to go with the underdogs disregarding the judges advices as if they never existed in the first place.

By: hunter

hunter — Thu, 07 Sep 2006 14:09:07 +0000

actually philippine idol rocks.. haahaaaaaha… i love the show… and i did vote!!! and im glad napasok sa top 4 yung ibinoto ko… hahahah.. di sayang ang load ko.. masaya pa ako.. sayang lang at telesulit landline namin.. i cant vote thru pldt landline tuloy.. hehehehheeh

By: andre santos

andre santos — Thu, 07 Sep 2006 09:28:45 +0000

Philippine idol is not merely on the commercialization and dramatization on discovering talents. You get the real thing. No frills…. No drama…just plain and naked singing talent..something new..something fresh….kaya nga ibinasura na ung isang dating winner galing sa ABS… singing search eh…un bang gumagaya kay Michael Bolton…whats his name again??? nakaka-umay na kasi xa eh…

By: goken

goken — Wed, 06 Sep 2006 15:55:51 +0000

idol fanatic, if philippine idol followed the Idol franchise standards to the letter, maganda sana yung labas ng show.. di sana full of technical glitches, DEAD AIR, substandard sets, et cetera… buti nlng talented talaga ang mga pilipino at nabawi ung mga shortcomings ng show.

and i think ang ibig sabihin ng blogger about the judges is that the judges arent FRANK ENOUGH. that THEY SUGARCOAT the contestants’ performances instead.

By: idol_fanatic

idol_fanatic — Wed, 06 Sep 2006 14:50:19 +0000

sabi nga ni mr c. you dont have the right to be disappointed kasi nga you didnt even dare to vote. kung gusto mo hindi ma disappoint THEN VOTE. thats the only way para makasama or manalo yung bet mo. REMEMBER. THIS IS AN IDOL FRANCHISE so kung ano yung RULES sa AMERICAN IDOL yan din ang rules sa PHILIPPINE IDOL. live with it. kung frank masyado ang mga judges. STANDARD na tlga yan. kasi nga IDOL series e.

VOTE FOR YNAH!!! text YNAH and send to 2339 after the show(Sept 9) till 8:30pm the next day.

By: jher

jher — Wed, 06 Sep 2006 05:33:52 +0000

wow such a smart comment from ramona. that will surely attract more viewers. :-P